Perry's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Ballad of CrippleKane]

I have been looking foward ot this day

By far, my favorite movie you have ever made. To be perfectly honest I am not a fan of some of your works, you havent made anything truly great especially in this way up to this point. And man did you make something here.

You really did know how to keep your animation and story consistent being music or the lyrics.

The art was just fantastic, the horse animation is probably the craziest part, honestly horse run cycles are fucking hard, thats why not many include them or need to include them in their movies, and I pretty much sat through the process of you ironing those out.

Good job Hans, I loved it.

AlmightyHans responds:

thanks man.

[FRED - Animated Series]

God bless you chris

god bless you

Oney responds:

dittos hunny scrunch

[Vintagebro's Halloween]

Wasnt very funny either

Art was cool I guess, didnt like the animation way too much. Twas decent

VintageBro responds:

I guess I can say, Ill work on it, well we all have to learn sometime right?

[RWD: 017]

Looks Good

for a first flash (not including the collab) I really admire your art style, but there were scenes where you had to animate something and you really cut down the detail level and it looked pretty bad. I think it has tons of potential yet, you really didnt go all the way with this project

You obviously draw a lot of inspiration from rtil as I can see in your art style, and Im not saying thats a bad thing, rtil is a great animator just made a connection
there, probably wrong, but meh.

The full body animation like the first scene where he kills nogfish, you kind of had animation but I couldn't distinguish what he did he kinda jump kicked but shot and the same time. The whole time the line density kept changing which made it look terribly inconsistent, in the first scene it showed him looking at a tv and the smoothing was like highish 50, but then it has a picture that looks like 0 smoothing and looked terrible.

These are signs that you did the over great time, but in animation you really need consistency in these things so work on that.

Keep it up, cant wait to see more out to you
-------------------------------------
----------------------
Ponies, Perry

jakeganz responds:

haha a lot of people say my stuff looks like rtil's, it's understandable. i'm trying to move myself away from him as i did draw a lot of inspiration from him.

[Animation: The Mathmatics]

Bad art

it didnt look good, wasnt set up well 12 fps is not good for fps at all 24 is good for fps and 30 is for tweens

PhiTuS responds:

that's awesome. you want a cookie?

[Awesome Gaiden]

Well Made

Pros:
-Well Animated
-Clear audio
-Well drawn
-Instead of going on a huge ass rant about all the problems you finally focused on one and did it well I enjoy seeing less rush on a concept and more coverage on it.

Cons:
-I think you doing a parody without a huge bunch of yelling would be a kind of nice to try, like I have only seen work of people yelling, that probably is part of your rushed style but Id like to see more mild parody's without all the rush.

Conclusion:
I enjoyed it, very well made but Id definetly like you to slow down for once and actually explain something in full extent, oh and jokes about balls of fat are kinda getting boring, all video games have them so we dont need to see them in every non compilation movie you make.

Egoraptor responds:

I don't understand what you're saying about the balls of fat thing.

Anyway thanks for the kind words. I look forward to when I can express my non-"awesome" humor, but that's for another time. :O

[Indie]

Metaphor

I like how you slipped in the metaphor how his clothing is indie (Textured) and his whole room is (textured) too but he himself is not.

Meebs responds:

SHUSH!

[Showreel 2007]

Wow

I usually dont look up to artists, but well that was amazing. I loved the pirate thing, it really seemed like it was locks/madness the whole time but I really appreciate this

RubberNinja responds:

Glad you liked it dude! :)

[The Man With No Face!]

Spookie!

Nice job Leet but try to make it longer next time.

Leet-Productions responds:

Thanks, I'll try harder next time.